critchat: Story Critique

A writing podcast that critiques short stories, books, and other media.

Evildoers Anonymous; or, Writing a Sympathetic Villain

May 31, 2022

A reading and critique of “Lost Road” by Potato.


Emdashed Hopes; or, Capturing Nuanced Emotion

May 16, 2022

A reading and critique of “The Mighty Fallen, the Weapons of War Perished” by Maggie.


Abandonment Issues; or, Delivering on the Opening

Apr 25, 2022

A reading and critique of “Abandoned” by Trashtalk.


Taste the Rainbow; or, A Diamond in the KDP Rough

Apr 11, 2022

In today’s episode, awk and Brady grapple with their roles as primary witnesses to the book “Mawing Rainbows.”


Call for Submissions: Möbius

Apr 4, 2022

Send in your response to this prompt for a chance at having your writing read on the show!


All Sci-Fi, No Character; or, Tat Hackers

Mar 28, 2022

In today’s episode, awk and Brady dive into the raw bits and bytes of a book called “Data Mine.” They discover magic tattoos, elite hackers, and a crazed axe murderer with a fetish for explosions.


Cartomancy; or, Writing a Strong Theme

Mar 21, 2022

A reading and critique of “Blankbird” by Laura Dalton.


Using Dialogue to Drive the Story; or, Taking Shots

Feb 28, 2022

A reading and critique of “Shot for Shot” by Pinkot.


Writing from an Alien Perspective; or, A Fresh Start

May 3, 2021

A reading and critique of “Sense of Scale” by MeatballMassacre.


Zombie Pigeons; or, Lost in Allegory

Mar 8, 2021

A reading and critique of “It’s Always Sunny on Sunday(s)” by BBSpoons.


Call for Submissions: Negative Space

Feb 15, 2021

Send in your response to this prompt for a chance at having your writing read on the show!


Un-Lightning in a Bottle; or, Misplaced in Time

Feb 8, 2021

A reading of “Thunder” by kilozombie.


Excess Violence; or, How to Write a Tragic Flaw

Feb 1, 2021

A reading and critique of “Excess” by Shain.


Tangled Up; or, First Chapter Syndrome

Dec 28, 2020

Some villagers hang around in today’s episode.


An Overwrought Opening; or, Loitering At Death’s Door

Jan 25, 2020

In today’s story, a man dies, a rosary is beheld, and fish guts are ruined forever.


Breathtaking; or, An Example of Blending Humor with Character

Dec 29, 2019

Today’s episode features a wholesome story about a ghost and his newfound hobby.


Any% No Context; or, An Incoherent Story

Dec 8, 2019

Gratuitous Latin, an incomprehensible plot, and the tragic death of a teacup feature in this first submission to “Return.”


Call for Submissions: Return

Nov 23, 2019

Send in your response to this prompt for a chance at having your writing read on the show!


Idealizing Ideas

Nov 17, 2019

Story ideas get talked about a lot. But do they deserve the attention? Today we’ll chat about idea-focused writers, the obsession with “originality,” and what to do if you don’t have anything to write about.


The Evil Perspective; or, He Who Writes Monsters

Sep 2, 2019

Some chat about perspective and monsters and the final submission to “Speechless.”


Characterization Through Description; or, A Sneeze of Surprise

Jun 17, 2019

In today’s submission to “Speechless,” a rat’s hoarding obsession gets out of control. As does the length of the introductory paragraph.


Excessive Punctuation; or, Signed, The Peasants

May 10, 2019

In this first submission to “Speechless,” a king faces the toughest challenge of his entire rule: some really nice penmanship.


An Introduction; or, Much Ado About Writing

Apr 28, 2019

A short introduction to the podcast and some chatting about the strange aura that envelopes all things writing.